Like most people, my life has not been a constant bed of roses and I’ve been no saint, but then again, I’ve never, ever implied I was.
Although it’s not a very easy thing to admit, I’ve had two serious affairs, both times cheating on the same person. One affair was passionate and beautiful, the other a complete mess I would rather not be reminded of. As a matter of fact, the boyfriend I cheated on was someone I don’t care to remember either.
Usually, whenever something negative happens to me, down the road I come to terms with it, forgetting the bad things and keeping the good locked in my memory. My first serious relationship is not something I carry much baggage over, but it wasn’t one of the shining moments of my life, that’s for sure. The memories of that period I tend to just ignore, chalking it up to being young. Having been around the block, I’ve lived just about every role in life there is.
I was about twenty-four, I believe, and we dated for three years. He was a bartender and get this, a part-time drag queen. I’ve got nothing against drag queens, but usually I’m attracted to more of the cowboy type. This relationship was certainly a result of my co-dependency. I settled since this guy cared about me and I was scared of being alone. A truly stupid route to take but at least I can admit it.
He wasn’t a very good drag queen. Matter of fact, he looked like a man in a dress. He didn’t do it often, but when he did I can’t say I was happy about it. Not because it was drag, but because he lip-synched like one of those dubbed Japanese Godzilla movies, his lips moving a good half second after the words were already heard. Not being able to dance to save his soul, he was just awful even though he was very popular, probably because he was a bartender, but he was also a handful. Extremely jealous and controlling, I let him control me.
I will say he was a lot of fun sexually, and perhaps that was one of the reasons I first started dating him. In an odd way, he could be very masculine when he wanted to be, having grown up in a rural town with only older brothers who hunted, fished and played sports. He was also extremely tough and cocky, probably a result of having to fight so hard being the runt of the family. A decent person, his traumatic childhood brought anger to the surface he should have been in therapy for.
Because we were young and way too involved in the Des Moines gay bar scene, alcohol played a large part in the drama of our lives. Knock down drag outs, broken plates, screaming…you want to talk about dysfunctional?
My friends and I used to joke about that scene in What’s Love Got to Do With It where Tina Turner walks into the hotel lobby, white suit covered in blood and a black eye. “I’ve got forty-five cents and a Mobil credit card, but I promise if you give me a room I’ll pay you back!”
Been there…done that.
People who know me now would be surprised I was involved in something like that, but hey, I finally wised up, got the hell out of there and moved onto the next level of co-dependency, each tier not nearly as negative as the one previous. I lived and each time I certainly learned, never quite making the exact same mistake twice.
The first affair happened a year and a half after we first started dating. We had moved down to Nashville for my singing career and by this time, I knew hanging onto this nowhere relationship wasn’t honest, but I didn’t know what to do, whining about it in my own head rather than taking control, as I should have.
And so began the cheating, the cruising around gay areas at night, every once and awhile sneaking out to some late bar, since my boyfriend worked the graveyard shift. It was at one of those one a.m. turn around areas that I met James, a young man from Little Rock who had the most beautiful eyes, a charming smile and light blonde hair. He was about 5’ 10” and a year younger than I.
It started off as just a sexual fling, but soon grew into something more, although the physical always has a great deal to do with it at that age. I saw James every week for at least three months and usually the encounters were in a car, sometimes at his place when his roommate was out, sometimes we’d just go for walks in the country, ending up alongside a winding stream, blanket spread on the ground. Although it’s difficult to condone any of this, it was very romantic and beautiful. A respite from all the baggage I carried around being with someone I didn’t love.
James didn’t seem to have any issues with me having a boyfriend, but oddly enough, it was James who did all the chasing, calling to ask me to dinner, talking into the night, things I wouldn’t necessarily call strictly a “fling”. As hypocritical as it sounds, I remember one day when he showed me a Faberge egg given to him by an older wealthy man he was seeing at the same time. Although I didn’t verbalize or show it, I was jealous, and that was the point I knew I was getting in too deep. Lord, the drama I’d have to deal with if my boyfriend ever found out, the screaming, the physicality, the guilt landing my way.
One afternoon, my boyfriend and I were walking down a long deserted corridor inside a mall on the south side of town, and soon, right around the corner came James, walking towards us, purely by accident. Nervous and scared as he walked past, I was sure the cat was going to be let out of the bag. But, James gave me a sidelong glance with no expression, my boyfriend didn’t notice a thing and he never found out.
I ended it one night in the spring when James called and asked to meet in a park, everything always seemed so sneaky and wrong when it came to our encounters. He sat in his car, waiting for me to extend an invitation to go for a drive or to suggest going back to his place, but I couldn’t.
“Is everything okay?” he asked.
“Yes, I guess so…I mean, well…I don’t really know what I mean, sorry,” I replied.
He looked so sad and sweet right then, but I couldn’t let this go any further. With my boyfriend we had an apartment, checking accounts, furniture, all the little things that make a foolish co-dependent person too scared to walk away from something they don’t want to be involved in.
James was just a fantasy, albeit a wonderful, fulfilling one, but still, a fantasy. He wasn’t with me every day when I made coffee before going to work, he didn’t watch TV with me when I was tired, he didn’t wrap presents for me at Christmastime and vice versa. He wasn’t “life”. My boyfriend was “life”.
Summoning up the courage to tell him what I was feeling, I simply couldn’t verbalize it and took the coward’s way out. “I can’t see you anymore James, I’m sorry.”
“Why not?” he asked, his eyes starting to mist.
“I just can’t do it. I’m really sorry, it’s not you,” I answered, knowing I was giving him little to understand.
“But I really like you…” he replied. Man, this was getting harder and harder for me.
“I’m sorry, I’ve got to go,” and with that I smiled at him and said goodbye. Soft raindrops had been falling during this short conversation between us and I could see his teardrops mimicking them. He looked at me with a confused sad expression and I immediately felt like the unkindest person to ever walk the earth. How dare I hurt such a sweet soul? Some people might not think of him as sweet since he was having an affair with someone already taken, but I certainly did think he was, and my memory still feels that.
As I drove away from his car in the parking lot I turned on the radio. It was a Friday night and the Opry was being simulcast on WSM. I always found it soothing to drive around Nashville and listen to the show. As I caught my last look at James, Roy Acuff was on the radio singing “Blue Eyes Crying In the Rain”. I’ve never forgotten that, or that beautiful boy who helped me forget the bed I had made myself, with this boyfriend I didn’t really like much.
I’m not ashamed of the affair, it was everything romance and escapism is supposed to be. But I am ashamed of having been in the relationship and staying there when I should have simply ended it. But that type of strength and adult responsibility wouldn’t come until many years later, when I left another relationship, this time a very wonderful and loving one, for the right reasons. The reasons I should have been cognizant of in this first relationship.
We stayed together another year and a half, moving back to Des Moines a few months after I stopped seeing James. The relationship back in Iowa was just as tedious as it had been in Nashville, just as violent, just as dysfunctional.
I began to spread my wings a little more, going out with friends again, and slowly, very slowly, maturing into my own person. As I got stronger and more certain of what I really wanted, our fights increased, mainly since I started arguing back, angry at my boyfriend for wanting to control me and tell me what to do. More certainly, I was angry at myself for having let it go on like this in the first place.
One August, my car was in the shop so I borrowed my mom’s little Ford Escort to get around. We decided to go out on a Saturday night and while socializing at the bar, my boyfriend proceeded to get drunk, getting very belligerent with me. Another friend of mine, Tom, was also pretty tight, so rather than let Tom drive home, I took him back to his place in the car, dropped him off and headed back to the bar to find my boyfriend.
Out he came from that bar, foaming at the mouth, literally beet red with anger. “Where the fuck have you been!?” he demanded. I reminded him I had taken Tom home since he was too drunk to drive.
“Shut the fuck up!” he screamed. “I’ve been sitting in that damn place for a half hour waiting for you. We’re leaving, now! Get out of the fucking drivers seat, I’m driving home!”
“But you can’t, you’re drunk, it’s my mom’s car and if anything happens…”
He interrupted me with, “I said, get out of the fucking car now!”
I was scared, yes, but I was also weak. Giving in, I moved to the passenger seat, while he kept ranting and raving, screaming at me as we drove the five blocks to the interstate on our way home.
The closer we got to the interstate the more fearful I became, not so much of him anymore, but of us killing someone else or ourselves in a drunken accident. He was swerving all over the road and I knew once he got up to high speeds it could be dangerous. Two blocks from the on ramp I told him, “Please let me drive, you’ll wreck the car!”
“Shut the fuck up!” he screamed at me.
“Please…please…stop the car, I’ll drive, I’m sober, you’ll wreck my mom’s car…” I pleaded.
“No! I’m going to drive this fucking car all the way home and you can keep your damn mouth shut…”
Just then what little sense I had returned, knowing a decision had to be made and that I had been stupid to be so timid before. Now it wasn’t just about us, there was a real possibility he was going to hurt somebody else on the road.
After one more pleading and one more “Fuck you!” from him, I grabbed the steering wheel and flung my left leg over the area dividing the driver from the passenger seat.
I said, “No! You’ll kill someone like this!”
He started screaming and hitting me, the blows raining down on my head one after the other, but I didn’t notice them. All I could think of was I had to stop this car from moving and get it away from him.
Putting my left foot on the brake as he punched me right in the jaw, the vehicle came to a sudden stop. His body lurched toward the steering wheel I held with my right hand as the left one tried to shield myself from the blows. Luckily, he was so drunk he wasn’t as agile as usual, so I managed to reach in front of him, quickly open the driver’s side door and yell, “Get out of the car! I can’t let you drive this car!”
I don’t remember what all he screamed at me, but he kept hitting me as I managed to push him out of the driver’s seat and onto the pavement. Since the car was stopped, he managed to raise himself up rather than fall, all the while pulling at my arm trying to force me out of the car. I managed to move over to the driver’s seat, foot still on the brake as he took my left arm, just below the bicep and sank his teeth into it. Although it was painful and his teeth cut the skin, I managed to push him completely out of the car, slam the door shut, put it in drive and speed off towards the nearest lot so I could park. Then I’d come back to get him, hoping I’d be able to calm him down without the danger of this vehicle nearby.
As I kicked the car into drive he grabbed onto the side of the trunk, then the bumper and the momentum of the vehicle pulled him down onto the pavement, dragging him a good ten feet before he finally let go.
Through the rear view mirror I could see him rising from the pavement, his face covered in blood. I drove another two blocks, saw a lot on my left, pulled in, put the car in park and locked it, throwing the keys in my pocket where he hopefully wouldn’t try to get them.
While I was intending to go back for him, it wasn’t necessary, since he came stumbling up the lots entrance within seconds. Weaving back and forth and out of breath, he’d obviously been running the whole way after me. The right side of his face was so banged up and swollen from the fall I could hardly recognize him.
The shock of the accident must have sobered him up, because now he was crying, no longer screaming at me or angry. He was now scared.
Just then, a police car pulled into the parking lot. They must have seen him stumbling down the street towards the lot.
For having been such a lunatic before, he now calmed down considerably, telling the police there was nothing wrong, he’d fallen down and was just coming after me because we were supposed to drive home. It was obvious to them this was a domestic dispute after talking to both of us. I was worried about him getting arrested and about myself getting in trouble too. I never told them what really happened but they did ask if I was okay to drive home. When I said yes, I was telling the truth. I had not drunk much that night and was fine.
“You need to get him to the hospital,” they told me. “He’s in bad shape.” By now, my boyfriend was sitting on the passenger side of the car slowly going into shock. He had stopped crying once he saw the cops but now he looked as if he was going to pass out.
“Are you okay?” they asked, and I still remember how concerned and nice they were to me. Obviously shaken up, I tried to handle the police in a calm way, containing the emotion, but I must have looked like a scared little boy.
“Your arm is bleeding” one of them said and I looked down to see a large open wound on my lower bicep, not gushing with blood, but certainly a mess.
To this day, I don’t know why the police didn’t press this matter further. They probably didn’t want to get involved and I seemed on the level. I said I would take him to the hospital, so they asked if I wanted them to follow us. I replied, “Yes, could you please follow me all the way, please…” I did not trust my boyfriend even though he seemed too scared and worn out to do anything more to me. The police must have sensed the fear because they assured me it would be okay and they’d stay right behind us.
As I climbed into the car and shut the door he started to cry again, almost pleading, “Don’t leave me, I know you’re gonna leave me...please don’t.”
I kept my head on this time, now I was the one with the power. I lied, telling him, “I’m not going to leave you. We’re going to the hospital emergency room.” For the rest of the ride he drunkenly leaned against the door, every once and awhile sniffling away the tears.
Thankfully, the police did follow us to the emergency room and I got my boyfriend inside where the staff immediately took him in. He was in awful shape and needed stitches on the side of his face. When he fell and got drug by the car, the pavement and gravel had cut him extremely close to one of his eyes. If he had held on longer he probably would have lost one.
I washed my own arm in the hospital restroom and waited for two hours in the waiting area before the nurse told me to go home and come back in a few hours, my boyfriend was sedated and there was nothing I could do. Why nobody said anything about my arm I don’t know, and I also don’t remember why I didn’t say anything about it either.
I went home and took a shower, putting alcohol and iodine on the bite mark, a fairly serious cut about an inch long. I couldn’t sleep at all, making up my mind I was going to leave this son of a bitch, perhaps even right now. Should I pack some things and just get the hell out of there?
A friend of mine came over to talk and said not to be rash, I was too keyed up to make a realistic decision. “How about waiting until the morning?” he suggested.
Four hours later I was back at the hospital and my boyfriend was in his room. Calm by now, he was also ashamed of himself, telling me he was sorry, it wouldn’t happen again, he was just drunk, he didn’t mean any of it, he never wanted to hurt me. His face was still a mess. Although cleaned up with no more blood visible, the left side was swollen like a grapefruit and his black eye was completely shut. As he started to cry in the hospital bed, the salt from his tears made his cuts sting even more.
“I’m sorry I tried to hurt you,” he told me as I sat on the bed, looking at this man I sometimes hated, sometimes needed just because I wanted somebody, anybody, by my side.
I seriously thought to myself, “But I’m the one who actually hurt you.” I didn’t say it out loud, but he was the one in the hospital bed, he was the one who’d probably need plastic surgery, he was the one who almost lost his eye. I was the one who had walked out of there and returned a few hours later with only a deep bite mark and some bruises on my face where his fists made contact.
I can’t leave him right now, I thought. I can’t just walk out on him while he’s pleading with me and apologizing. I did this to him, so I can’t leave him.
I know now, and actually knew then, deep down, it wasn’t my fault. It was his fault. But still, the little boy in me felt very guilty that morning on a hospital bed looking at the broken man I’d been with almost three years, most of them unhappily. God, I was an emotional mess then, never knowing what was right for me.
I did stay with him for another three months. All my codependency came back after I felt sorry for him, but it didn’t last long. Two months later, after he’d healed a little, the screaming started once more and my self-loathing for remaining in this relationship began again.
And what did I do? What did that co-dependent young idiot who was always afraid there was “no tomorrow” do?
I had another affair, this time as simply a way to get the hell out of this awful mess on my own emotional terms. If I left my boyfriend when someone else cared about me, then I wouldn’t be alone at all now, would I? Someone would still be there for me and therefore, I wouldn’t be crying half the time because I was unhappy.
We had one more incredibly huge blow up, this time without fists and cars, but still, enough to make me backtrack on those first feelings of pity on a hospital bed. Alcohol was once again involved and he got belligerent, this time throwing in my face, “I’m probably fucking scarred for life because of you!”
Enough. I stayed with my best friend that night and returned to the apartment the next morning, not saying a word. When he awkwardly apologized I went about my business and didn’t answer.
“You’re leaving me, aren’t you?” he calmly asked.
“Yes I am,” I replied.
“I’m sorry, please don’t go, we can work this out…”
“No, we can’t and I don’t want to work this out. I’m very sorry, but it’s over.”
He had tears in his eyes and told me he would leave and that I could keep the apartment. He’d stay at his brother’s house. He said, “I love you very much,” and walked out the door.
Because of the violent way things had always worked out with him, I was surprised it ended so quickly and calmly on his part. Two days later, when I came home from work I discovered my little dog, Kiri, gone. She was a sweet little blonde mutt who loved me unconditionally but my boyfriend had gotten angry again, come into the apartment while I was gone and taken her.
Great, more drama, only this time he had really gotten back at me, hitting me right where it hurt. I called on the phone asking for the dog back, but by now he was in his “sly and coy” mode, as if he were holding all the cards, thinking he still had power over me. He had only taken Kiri out of spite, and admitted so, very much gloating over it on the phone.
“I’ll think about giving her back. Maybe I will and maybe I won’t.” I never saw that little dog again.
The reason he was so mad this time was because he found out about my second affair since I told him point blank about it. To him, he now had a reason to be vengeful.
I’m not proud of this section of my life, but it happened and there’s nothing I can do about the past. The only reason I was able to leave that man was because I had another waiting for me. All this drama, with me not taking one ounce of responsibility.
The guy I left my boyfriend for was simply a means to an end, perhaps I knew it at the time, I don’t know, but that next relationship only lasted three months before I ended it, this time a little more like an adult. The second guy was not even close to what I wanted in a partner, but it got me out of that previous dysfunction, so it must have served a purpose. You can’t go back and change things, but you can damn well make sure you grow up enough so they don’t repeat themselves.
And to this very day, I have a scar on my lower bicep. You can make out the curve of teeth in it, about an inch long. I would have preferred a photograph as a reminder, but in a way, I suppose every time I look at it I know I will never, ever go through such a thing again.